Often, these stories are things that happened to a friend of a friend--so common that it is known as a FOAF by people who study urban legends. Although they're not necessarily fabrications, most of the juiciest urban legends--like the one about the babysitter who cooked the baby instead of a turkey--have never been proven.
You've most likely received at least one urban legend in your e-mail inbox. I know I've received a fake Neiman Marcus cookie recipe at least five times. I might have believed it, too, if I hadn't also gotten a photocopy of a fake Mrs. Fields cookie recipe in the early 1980s. I believed that one was real, until I baked the cookies--they weren't even close to the real Mrs. Fields's. Still, that wasn't my first urban legend. The first one I heard was a Halloween warning that people were giving out LSD-laced Mickey Mouse tattoos instead of candy. Every kid I knew was freaked out about getting one, and it was all for nothing. The story just wasn't true.
It sure seemed like it could be, though, and this is one of the reasons people believe urban legends. According to Brunvand and others, we're eager to believe these stories because:
- They seem like they might be true. Either someone we trust is telling it, or it happened to a FOAF.
- They're good stories--scary or memorable or funny.
- They carry a message, one that confirms a world-view, such as that Neiman Marcus is greedy or that parents are bad for leaving their kids with babysitters.
These are some of the same reasons we tell urban legends, too--with an addition of the "just-in-case" clause. Just in case it's true, I'll be doing a service if I pass the word along, right?
Many of these same forces help keep old wives' tales alive, too. Although old wives' tales don't usually contain a FOAF (and instead dispense nuggets of motherly wisdom and rules), we often believe them just the same. This is because it might somehow really be bad for the groom to see the bride before the wedding. Or, swallowed gum really might remain in your stomach forever. (Neither is true; and although gum can't be digested, it does pass through your system.)